On Tuesday, the EU Commission announced its preliminary findings in the ongoing review of the Chinese marketplace Temu. According to the Commission, the platform violates Article 35 of the EU’s Digital Services Act (DSA) by failing to take sufficient and effective measures to limit the spread of illegal products.
Today’s announcement means that the EU is opening a new front against the e-commerce giant. As Ehandel.se reported in May, Temu was fined 200 million euros, equivalent to approximately 2.2 billion Swedish kronor, for violating Article 34 regarding insufficient risk assessment. As recently as late October, Ehandel.se reported that the Commission approved the action plan that Temu was forced to submit following the spring fines, but now the new allegations concern how the platform practically handles product safety.
Shopping online should not mean risking the purchase of illegal and unsafe products. According to the DSA, platforms are obliged to protect users from the risk of illegal content and dangerous goods. The preliminary findings against Temu mark another step towards a safer digital world, says Henna Virkkunen, the EU Commission’s Executive Vice-President responsible for technological sovereignty, security and democracy.
Deficiencies in testing and moderation
In its investigation, the EU Commission points to three main areas where Temu’s procedures are deemed inadequate. The first point concerns ineffective product controls. According to the Commission, Temu only requires test reports for a very small proportion of the goods on the platform, and in many cases, the documentation is not reviewed when submitted. Physical samples are also not prioritized in high-risk categories such as toys, electronics and cosmetics, while control measures have not been scaled up as the platform’s product range has grown.
The second deficiency concerns the platform’s content moderation. The Commission notes that the review of new advertisements primarily focuses on the advertisement text itself and compliance with the platform’s own terms of use, rather than verifying the actual safety of the products. In addition, the number of human moderators has not increased at the same rate as the number of advertisements published on the marketplace.
The third area concerns what the Commission describes as ineffective sanctions against unscrupulous traders. When Temu takes action, it is directed at the individual digital store rather than at the business operator behind the operation. As a single seller often operates multiple stores on the platform, an actor who has had a store shut down can continue its sales through other accounts. According to the investigation, sellers can also commit a large number of serious violations before a store is closed down at all.
Demands for continued supervision
The review of Temu was initiated after the European Consumer Organisation BEUC and 17 national member organizations, including Swedish Consumers, submitted a joint notification two years ago. In a press release on Tuesday, Swedish Consumers welcomed the Commission’s announcement, but also highlighted a new report from BEUC showing that similar deficiencies also occur on other major marketplaces such as Aliexpress, Shein and Amazon.
This is very serious criticism directed at Temu. But we know that more platforms are just as bad. So supervision must continue, says Yasemin Bayramoglu, Communications Manager at Swedish Consumers.
The organization points out that the coordinated notifications at EU level have been crucial in bringing about concrete reviews of e-commerce platforms.
The EU Commission’s announcement today is very important. It is a direct result of the notification we made together with other consumer organizations and it shows how important it is that we work together across borders when we see that consumer safety is threatened, says Yasemin Bayramoglu.
Risks six percent of turnover
The EU’s tightened scrutiny and new regulations regarding trade with third countries have already begun to affect market dynamics in the Nordic region. Earlier in November, Ehandel.se reported on how Temu has lost ground in Denmark and fallen out of the top tier among the most used online stores after the introduction of the EU’s new customs rules.
Temu now has the opportunity to review the Commission’s investigation material and submit a written response in its defense. If the EU Commission then chooses to confirm its preliminary findings, a formal decision on non-compliance can be made. Such a decision may involve new fines of up to six percent of Temu’s total global annual turnover, as well as demands for immediate measures to remedy the safety deficiencies.